Skip to main content
 
 
 

Fire Investigation Update 2020

Fire Investigation Update 2020

Fire investigation Keith Borer Consultants damage arson endanger life

The ‘Code of Practice for Investigators of Fire and Explosions for the Criminal Justice System in the UK’ (https://www.ife.org.uk/write/MediaUploads/Documents/Fire_Investigation_Code_of_Practice.pdf)has been in operation since April 2017, yet KBC experts continue to encounter fire investigation cases that fall well short of what is now expected.

Documentation

In a recent case we were asked to review a large fire scene as a paper exercise, relying on the report, notes and photographs of the prosecution expert.  The report was extensive, but the notes and images underpinning it were sadly lacking in key detail.  Indeed the only images made available to us in the case had been downloaded by the prosecution investigator from ‘social media (source unknown)’.  They had not taken any of their own scene photographs to support their opinions and conclusions regarding the origin and cause of the fire.

Appropriate documentation of a fire scene is essential both as an aide memoire for the original investigator, and to enable a future review of the original scene by experts who are instructed after the scene is reinstated.  Without sufficient documentation it may not be possible for an expert to fully support their opinions or exclude alternative reasons for the fire.  We produced a report highlighting a number of issues.  The Crown discontinued the case.

Physical Evidence

Analysis and preservation of physical items can also be an issue.  A fire in a bedroom was documented with scene photographs that showed fire damage was confined almost entirely to the bed.  The defendant stated that, on the morning of the fire, she used a heated belt on the bed to relieve pain; she had then left the house.  The prosecution fire investigator found what he described as a mobile phone type charger plugged into an electrical socket in the bedroom, but he found no trace of electrical wiring for a heated belt on the bed.  His investigation concluded the fire was started deliberately.  KBC was instructed to review the evidence from the papers and photographs.  Our report noted that the heated belt was battery-powered and had a mobile-phone type charger, which was consistent with the physical evidence but that evidence had not been properly examined or retained to check further. Given the presence of the unidentified charger in the room and the potential for battery-powered products to cause fires, the heated belt was considered a credible alternative fire cause to that offered by the Crown.  After submitting our report, the Crown offered no evidence.

Scene preservation

The lack of scene preservation and insufficient documentation/ information can lead to improperly-considered conclusions that are not scientifically sustainable.  The fire service was alerted to a fire in a wooden building located close to a large bonfire.  The first crew found the building well alight.  The initial fire incident report gave the cause of the fire as ‘accidental’.  Two prosecution fire investigators subsequently accessed the scene six and ten days after the fire.  In the intervening period, the scene had not been preserved, had been substantially disturbed and partially cleared.  The building in question was constructed of readily-combustible materials, there was evidence of additional combustible fuels being stored within, and the fire occurred during a warm, dry summer.  Dried vegetation was in the immediate vicinity.

Fire tests by one of the prosecution investigators demonstrated this vegetation burned fiercely once lit and in a manner that could have ignited the building.  At odds with the initial fire incident report and without apparent consideration of the ignition tests, both prosecution investigators concluded the most likely cause of the fire was deliberate ignition with a naked flame, and that there was no likelihood that a flying brand from the bonfire caused the fire.  KBC’s investigation found that, due to the lack of scene preservation, the precise status of the scene pre- and post-fire was not known and could not be established.  The available evidence and the results of the ignition tests demonstrated that the fire could have been started deliberately with a naked flame or via a flying brand from the bonfire; it was not possible to eliminate either of these as a potential cause.  At trial half time the judge halted the case due to the reasonable possibility it was an accidental fire.

What can KBC do for you?

The Government requires all fires in the UK to be ‘investigated’ by the fire service and a most likely cause ascertained for data collection and statistical analysis purposes.  There is no requirement that suspected arson fires be investigated thoroughly and this responsibility lies with the Police.  On occasion and through no fault of their own, some fire officers with little training and experience of fire investigation find themselves nominated the prosecution expert in cases involving charges as serious as arson with intent to endanger life.  Their report may be written following no more than a cursory visual ‘examination’ of the scene.

In cases like these, it can be hard to determine from the initial papers that the ‘evidence’ is more of a data collection exercise for statistical reporting and not a properly detailed examination and recording of the scene by an expert for criminal prosecution purposes.  Our experts at KBC are well accustomed to reviewing others’ work and can quickly identify the strengths and limitations of the Prosecution’s evidence once we begin our own, more-detailed investigations.

Fire investigation is a very complex area of forensic science and there are many steps needed in properly considering ALL of the relevant evidence in each case.  If you have a case where the outcome of a fire investigation is an issue, or you simply want an initial chat about a fire case, then please contact us for help and advice.  We have seen a number of fire cases where the disclosed report is outwardly convincing but, on more detailed inspection of the supporting materials by our experts, critical deficiencies have been identified in scene examination procedure and/or interpretation of the evidence.

Our fire investigation experts, Jennefer Gray, Alan Henderson and Dr David Schudel can be contacted at the Durham office on 0191 332 4999.

Subscribe To Mailing List

To unsubscribe click here

What our customers say...

  • Mr Brown was an impressive witness. As far as I am concerned, you can give him full marks all round.

    Counsel, March 2020
  • Communication and speed of delivery of information was, as always, excellent.

    Solicitor, April 2020
  • I have had the pleasure of the assistance of Mike Appleby on a number of occasions now and he is an excellent man to have around. 

    Counsel, March 2020
  • We have used your services for some time and are very satisfied.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Thank you for your hard work in this case and for the prompt responses. 

    Barrister, March 2020
  • Found the service to be extremely helpful, given the timeframe in which the report was required.

    Solicitor, January 2020
  • Quality service, helpful staff, prompt reports.  Our company has used Keith Borer Consultants for many years.

    Solicitor - February 2019
  • Richard Brown always provides accurate and impartial advice, which makes the advocate’s job so much easier when advising clients or presenting the case in court.

    Barrister – November 2018
  • Thanks to Sarah Morley for her help: her evidence was very important in bringing this case to justice and it is greatly appreciated.

    Solicitor - August 2019
  • Thank you for writing the report so quickly. Very helpful.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • Very fast, professional, easy to instruct.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • I instructed Mr Armstrong on a recommendation from another counsel and will certainly recommend him to my colleagues in future.

    Barrister – November 2018
  • Mr Prime reported to us with great efficiency and presented his evidence to the Jury in an extremely persuasive manner.

    Counsel, March 2020
  • Have used you before and always found you efficient and easy to deal with.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • We have been using your services for a number of years and have always been very happy with the service provided.

    Solicitor - April 2019
  • Have used Keith Borer in the past for many different types of reports and would do so again.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • Quick and efficient; and well laid out report.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Please pass on my gratitude to Mr Marryat for being able to compile a report in such a quick turnaround. Much appreciated.

    Solicitor, August 2019
  • Prompt and efficient communication, met the deadline, carried out the instructions.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Always try to instruct, if possible, due to excellent service provided.

    Solicitor, September 2019
  • Please thank Sarah Morley for her sterling work.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • Both our client and I were very impressed by your expert evidence. I will be singing your praises for years to come.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • We have been instructing KBC for the last 20 years or so, and they are listed as our first choice on our database. I have never had any cause for complaint and the experts have always acted with integrity and professionalism.

    Solicitor – January 2019
  • Have used many times previously and always been extremely satisfied with the service and reports.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • You guys are simply the best.

    Solicitor - September 2018
  • Attentive. Quick. Professional.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • Mr Armstrong was very professional and presented his analysis to the Jury in a very helpful way.

    Barrister – July 2019
  • We have used KBC on many occasions in the past and have always had a reliable service.

    Solicitor, April 2020
  • Great report - it really shows off your skills compared to the prosecution (so-called) experts. Thanks so much.

    Counsel - June 2018
  • Brilliant job and response to late and urgent instructions – very much above and beyond what we would expect.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • Mr Cook’s evidence was clear and concise and did not waiver under cross-examination.  His efforts in this case are greatly appreciated.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Adrian Armstrong is an excellent witness who easily out-shone the police expert.

    Barrister - November 2018
  • Mr Brown and the work he did were excellent in every respect.  We are grateful to him for his prompt and professional assistance.

    Solicitor – September 2018
  • Good service, prompt, efficient, have used many times in the past.

    Solicitor, April 2020
  • The website had all the key words that I was looking to see for an expert in the area of interest.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Mr Dampier made an incredibly complicated matter easy to understand.

    Barrister, February 2020
  • The Evidence given by Mr Dunnill resulted in the trial of issue being found in the client's favour, thereby avoiding immediate custodial sentence.

    Barrister, August 2019
  • Richard Brown is an excellent expert witness.

    Barrister – November 2018
  • I found the service to be very professional throughout.

    Solicitor, October 2019
  • I would like to thank you both for all your help on this case, and the tasks you had to perform at short notice.  Your assistance was greatly appreciated.

    Solicitor - May 2019
  • Just a very high quality, professional service.

    Solicitor, December 2019
  • I have to thank you for all the help you have given me in preparing for this and in giving your evidence, which I think was very convincing and went a long way to this acquittal. 

    Solicitor - March 2019
  • Always a pleasure working with you guys; our first choice for instruction.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Amazing!

    Counsel – July 2018
  • Many thanks for your very helpful and professional report.

    Solicitor – June 2019
  • Mike Appleby's exceptional quality was noted by all of the Counsel involved in the case. It is always a pleasure to watch someone, who is good at something, doing it and doing it well.

    Barrister, December 2019
  • Consistently reliable. Reports are very easy to read.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • John Tarpey's expert report was full and allowed me to present the material to the court effectively and allowed me, with his assistance, to effectively challenge the prosecution expert's assertions.

    Barrister – November 2018
  • I will definitely use Dr Schudel in the future and will be recommending him to my colleagues.

    Counsel, March 2020
  • There are times when DNA evidence can be a little dry, but Mike Appleby's presentation and delivery to the jury was pitch perfect.

    Barrister, December 2019
  • I found the quality of the report very high, and I am aware that Dr Davey had to work hard to hit the deadline because of other commitments.

    Solicitor – January 2019
  • Quick telephone answering, excellent understanding of the issues facing us i.e. prior authority, court dates changing at last moment, need for rapid responses.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • It is always easy to contact KBC and to get a prompt reply.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • Clear communication, very good advice, good quality of forensic report.

    Solicitor – January 2019
  • Mr Armstrong impressed throughout the trial as a real expert in his field. It was apparent too that Mr Armstrong was entirely impartial.

    Counsel, March 2020
  • We were kept updated throughout the process and the report was provided promptly.

    Solicitor, January 2020
  • We would be extremely grateful if you could thank Ms Gray again for her incredible report.

    Solicitor - March 2019
  • Extremely good customer service and continuous contact/support.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Prompt attention to dealing with queries and providing information and reports.

    Solicitor, March 2020
  • Report prepared well and is a format we could understand. Written in a way that the lay person can understand.

    Solicitor – June 2018
  • Mike Prime’s presentation on paper, in conferences and from the witness box was excellent on what is a very difficult and sad case.  My client’s family particularly wished to express their gratitude.  They found that he made “more sense than the prosecution expert”.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Alan Henderson was excellent.  Very knowledgeable on this area of law.  Provided an excellent report, with speed.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • We have used you many times before and have never been anything but entirely satisfied. We will continue to do so.

    Solicitor – June 2018
  • I cannot speak more highly of the quality of the report.  Mr Prime is now my ‘go to’ expert.

    Solicitor – September 2018
  • Efficient and helpful in a complex case.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • Prompt provision of report and prompt reply to queries.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Easy to read report.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • I found Mr Prime to be a very good natured and competent expert witness who presented well in the witness box.

    Barrister – July 2019
  • Helpful, speedy and good quality.

    Solicitor – May 2019
  • Easy to use BAC calculation form, fast turn around.

    Solicitor, September 2019
  • Thank you very much, again, for the professionalism of your expert witnesses.

    Barrister – November 2018
  • Excellent communication, timescales met despite difficulties with police & CPS.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • Quick response to our request; friendly members of staff.

    Solicitor – September 2018
  • Efficient and very responsive.

    Solicitor - April 2019
  • Prompt and reliable service.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Complete satisfaction with services.

    Solicitor, September 2019
  • Simon Bunter is as good an expert as I have ever worked with.

    Barrister, December 2019
  • Reasonably priced compared to other experts.

    Solicitor – May 2019
  • The prosecutor found Dr Davey's report particularly well considered which undoubtedly informed his decision not to proceed with the case. Can I thank you very much for your help in this matter.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • Quick response, easily contactable.  Never had to instruct expert for this type of report and you provided us with all the information to enable us to request the necessary consent from CPS etc.  Very helpful.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • After the initial phone call, I knew I had contacted the right organisation.  The report just reaffirmed what I already knew.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Reliable and trustworthy.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • Service had a quick turnaround and any queries were quickly addressed.

    Solicitor - March 2019
  • Very quick turnaround, with attention to detail and helpful comments.

    Solicitor, January 2020
  • Mr Cook’s report was easy to follow for those who are not experts in this field and explained the method and conclusion fully.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Mr Beatson was very helpful and professional, clearly with a wide range of knowledge and understanding.

    Solicitor, March 2020
  • Mr Cook completed the report very quickly and to a high standard, despite the very short timeframe in which he was given.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Clear information about cost, speed and efficiency of report.

    Solicitor - March 2019
  • Extremely efficient.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • Extremely quick and efficient.

    Solicitor – September 2018
  • Easy to find on Google and seemed like decent, legitimate company at decent price.

    Private client - March 2019
  • Jenny Gray was excellent and very helpful throughout.

    Barrister, November 2019
  • Excellent reports within Legal Aid rates.

    Solicitor, November 2019
  • Speed, efficiency and accuracy.

    Solicitor – June 2018
  • Your service was exemplary.

    Solicitor – January 2019
  • The service was both timely and accurate - exactly what was required in a developing trial.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • I have previously attended a demonstration of the techniques used by the experts at Keith Borer Consultants.  What they can achieve is genuinely astonishing.  I require my instructing solicitor to immediately contact Keith Borer Consultants and seek out their assistance.

    Colin Buckle, Barrister – September 2018
  • Overall helpful and efficient service.

    Solicitor, September 2019
  • Mr Prime attended punctually on each day of this case.  He possesses a very approachable and helpful attitude.

    Solicitor – October 2018
  • Extremely prompt service.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • I am very impressed by your service.

    Solicitor, February 2020
  • Friendliness and complete empathy in what was a very stressful situation for me.

    Private client – September 2018
  • I have instructed you for many years and always find yourselves to be helpful, efficient and reports are prepared in an easy to digest format.

    Solicitor, October 2019
  • Exceptional service.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • Your report is fantastic and much appreciated.

    Private client - April 2019
  • Mrs Allan gave extremely clear evidence.

    Barrister – July 2019
  • Very thorough report.

    Solicitor – June 2018
  • Fiona Taylor provided quick responses to all of my questions and queries. The service was very professional throughout, from my initial enquiry to receiving the Report.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • I can say that I am very satisfied with the service I have received from KBC, starting with my initial phone call and interaction your colleague when I made my initial enquiry, right up to the report being received. I would certainly use KBC again and would recommend you to my colleagues.

    Solicitor, January 2020
  • We’ve had years of excellent service from you.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • Dr Helen Davey was, as always, excellent. From her initial report to her attendance at a conference and court. Her expertise is apparent and her ability to explain difficult issues is outstanding.

    Counsel – August 2018
  • Mr Appleby was truly excellent. While giving evidence it was plain that he has achieved the perfect blend of clarity and authoritative charisma.

    Barrister, December 2019
  • Richard Brown was excellent and his professional manner/quality of evidence won the day for us - compared with the prosecution expert! Quality counts!

    Solicitor - June 2018
  • No improvement needed.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • We have used KBC for many years: always helpful, plenty of experts & LAA seems to be happy with estimates for CRM4 application purposes.

    Solicitor - August 2019
  • Known to us as credible experts, who provide a first class service.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • Fast service; timely response to communication.

    Solicitor, January 2020
  • I am really grateful for your assistance in this case; I am sure it made the pivotal difference.

    Solicitor – May 2019
  • Please pass on my thanks to Emma Youngson for the speed at which she completed the report; I am very grateful.

    Solicitor - July 2019
  • We find you reliable and expeditious.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • Eager to assist at very short notice and very helpful on the phone.

    Solicitor – May 2019
  • I was very impressed both with the clarity of Dr Davey’s report to the layperson, and her even-handedness. The objective tone of the report and the fact that the opposing party’s expert agreed with the analysis gave Dr. Davey’s evidence a huge amount of credibility. I would recommend her to anyone in need of similar evidence and have no doubt that her evidence was vital to us winning the case.

    Diarmuid Laffan, Barrister - June 2019
  • Thank you for getting back to me so quickly. This is exactly what we needed.

    Solicitor – July 2019
  • Based on many previous instructions to assist with our cases, the reports produced by your Experts are always helpful.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • Please thank Orla Sower for her excellent work on this case.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • Simon Bunter is extraordinarily knowledgeable, remarkably efficient and a wonderful communicator. I cannot recommend him highly enough.

    Barrister, December 2019
  • Always a good service.

    Solicitor – September 2018
  • Swift service.

    Solicitor, March 2020
  • I was delighted by Mrs Tweedy's professional and thorough approach.

    Mr Saltrese - September 2019
  • We have used KBC for our forensic requirements for many years. The service has always been excellent, timely and useful.

    Solicitor – November 2018
  • We were impressed by the quality of the report and competitive cost.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • Alan Henderson was a very knowledgeable witness, clearly very familiar with his subject matter and capable of explaining it too. I would not hesitate to use him in the future.

    Barrister, August 2019
  • Helen Davey’s report is excellent, as are all the reports that she has written for us.  She is always very willing to provide advice and answer questions and is also a very nice person.

    Solicitor – July 2018
  • Jenny Gray acted with the utmost integrity throughout. This was noted in open court by the judge hearing the case.

    Solicitor, October 2019
  • We are very grateful to Mr Marryat for all the hard work he has done for us.

    Solicitor – June 2019
  • We are especially impressed by the Expert's willingness to discuss a case over the telephone before a formal instruction and the fast turnaround for completion of reports.

    Solicitors – June 2018
  • Great communication and updates.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • Prompt and efficient handling of initial enquiries and arrangements to inspect Prosecution exhibits.

    Solicitor - March 2019
  • Quick, efficient and professional.

    Solicitor - February 2019
  • Very quick response to both our initial email enquiry and all emails. Helpful and approachable staff and experts.

    Solicitor – August 2018
  • Easy to contact, quick responses (particularly in the current circumstances), very helpful staff.

    Solicitor, April 2020
  • Comprehensive and comprehendible expert’s report; first class response to queries.

    Solicitor – December 2018
  • I was very grateful to your Mike Prime for assistance he gave me on a case recently when he went out of his way to assist, despite the fact a trial was imminent and it became clear I would not have the chance to formally instruct at that point. I thought that was very impressive.

    Solicitor – October 2018

Keith Borer Consultants is a division of Orchid Cellmark Ltd, a company registered in England at 16 Blacklands Way, Abingdon, OX14 1DY.

Registered No. 4045527; VAT registration No. GB 750 0292 64

Website developed by Problue Solutions