Skip to main content

DNA evidence – what is the value of an SFR1 ‘DNA Match Report’?

DNA evidence – what is the value of an SFR1 ‘DNA Match Report’?

DNA evidence - what is the value of an SFR1 DNA match report?

The application of Streamlined Forensic Reporting for DNA profiling, particularly in rape and serious sexual offences, is problematic and needs careful consideration if miscarriages of justice are to be avoided.

A Streamlined Forensic Report Stage 1 ‘DNA match’ (SFR1 DNA match report) gives the results of DNA profiling.  It will indicate the type of DNA profiling undertaken for both the recovered and reference samples, and give an indication of whether the resulting recovered profile was mixed with more than one contributor.  An SFR1 DNA match report is intended to be a case progression tool, not evidence in its own right.

Only a tiny proportion of cases progress from an SFR1 DNA match report to an SFR2 DNA evaluation report, in which an expert has assessed the evidential value of that match.  Effectively, therefore, for the majority of cases, in which SFR1 DNA match reports are accepted and SFR2 reports are not prepared, there is an evidential value being assumed by the recipients of SFR1 DNA match reports.  From a scientific standpoint, a DNA profile match will have no evidential value until its evaluation in the case context indicates that it does have.  The relevance of contextual issues in relation to DNA profiling evidence are set out in a publication by The Royal Society, ‘Primer: Forensic DNA analysis’[1]. Evaluation requires expert knowledge of the context and available research.

Acceptance by the defence of an SFR 1 means the prosecution do not seek any further expert opinion by SFR2.  In accepting an SFR1, however, it is important for the defence to be precise about exactly what is accepted and to avoid inadvertent acceptance of a whole raft of assumptions and inferences that might seem to flow from the test result.  Ideally, prosecutors should demonstrate evidential significance, by expert evidence if necessary, rather than allow maximum pro-prosecution value to be inferred which may then require the defence to prove otherwise.

Ultimately, courts need to be satisfied that the DNA which matches a defendant was in a quantity and type of cellular material which fits with an allegation, and was transferred at the time and in the manner alleged; none of which is indicated by an SFR1.  A full matching DNA profile can provide compelling evidence in some contexts and be evidentially valueless in others, or sit somewhere in between.  If a DNA profile match cannot, in itself, prove an allegation, then it follows that the degree to which it might support that allegation is dictated by the likelihood of obtaining the same result from other circumstances.  Accurate evidential evaluation depends on assessing the limitations of the sampling and testing, and the extent to which the result could have arisen from other stated or reasonable alternative circumstances.

Our recommendation to defence lawyers is to be explicit that acceptance of an SFR1 DNA match report does not include acceptance that it necessarily corroborates an allegation or deems acceptance of a prosecution lawyer’s inferences.  Thereafter, its uncertainty may be dealt with by instructing forensic experts.  We can establish the source and location of the underlying scientific data and disclosure can be obtained, allowing expert evaluation of the DNA profiling result within the context of the case.

By all means, choose to accept an SFR1 DNA match report as an accurate test result – but no more than that. 

Dr Duncan Woods


Subscribe To Mailing List

To unsubscribe click here

What our customers say...

  • Alan Henderson was absolutely fantastic.

    Mr Wood, Appleby Hope & Matthews Solicitors – October 2017
  • Communication overall was excellent.

    Ms Stevens, Coroner’s Office Northern Ireland - May 2017.
  • Very prompt professional service.

    Mr Gaubert, Favell Smith & Lawson Solicitors – November 2017
  • Mr Armstrong was excellent in every respect.  I will seek to instruct him in every future RTA case.

    Mr Gray, Drystone Chambers - November 2016.
  • Good quality work.

    Ms Ridge, Howells Solicitors - December 2017
  • Well established reputation for forensic work.

    Mr Reid, Gerard Maguire Solicitors – October 2017
  • Your firm remains my first choice for collision expert reports.

    Mr Maher, Patterson Law - November 2017
  • Very approachable.

    Ms Hunt, Wiseman Lee LLP Solicitors - May 2017.
  • Mr Prime was very fair and provided assistance beyond the report.

    Ms Nicholson, Kellocks Solicitors – August 2017.
  • That is a very good statement; please thank Ms Kiernan for me.

    Mr Stojsavljevic, Berkeley Square Solicitors - December 2017
  • Very impressive and thoroughly excellent performance in the witness box.

    Mr Alonsi, Black Chambers – February 2018
  • Mark Henderson was always available to discuss the case.

    Ms Cath McClenan, Paisleys Solicitors - June 2017.
  • Clarity of communications.

    Mr Patterson, Howard Bernstein Solicitors – October 2017
  • Quick, knowledgeable and easy to deal with.

    Ms Conway, Howard Bernstein & Co Solicitors – July 2017.
  • Cheapest and clearest quote.

    Mr Mock, Everett Tomlin Lloyd & Pratt Solicitors - June 2016.
  • What is particularly helpful is the opening of other avenues of enquiry which hadn't been previously considered.

    Ms Cath McClenan, Paisleys Solicitors - June 2017.
  • Compassionate and professional attitude.

    Private client – March 2018
  • As always, I am entirely satisfied by the services provided by your company.  These are provided to the highest level.

    Mr Turner, Hewitts Solicitors – January 2018
  • I use KBC regularly and trust the results.

    Mr Mellody, M K Law Solicitors - April 2017.
  • Always receive a prompt and efficient service.

    Ms Cath McClenan, Paisleys Solicitors - June 2017.
  • Always very quick, but also thorough and well written. Always very professional.

    Ms Burgess, L P Evans Solicitors – November 2017
  • Many thanks, Duncan, for the quick turnaround. I can always rely on KBC!

    Mr Kampanella, E B R Attridge Solicitors - November 2016.
  • We]did a generic Google trawl and ‘short-listed’ you because of your experience/credentials but (having contacted others) selected you because you were efficient, quick off the mark and personable.

    Ms S, Private Client – April 2018
  • I prefer your company because you are relatively local and approachable.

    Mr O’Connor, Brockbanks Solicitors – March 2018
  • Very efficient and helpful to deal with.

    Mr Burke, David Burke & Company Solicitors - January 2017.
  • Able to quickly speak to the people dealing with the matter.

    Mr Lloyd, The Lee Rigby Partnership Solicitors - November 2016.
  • Have used several times previously and always had excellent service from Keith Borer Consultants.

    Ms Thompson, John H Smith Solicitors – August 2017.
  • Exceptionally quick turnaround time.

    Mr Whittaker, Walsh Solicitors - March 2017.
  • Helpfully swift responses – in respect of both fee estimates and reports.

    Mr Hayler, Old Bailey Solicitors – January 2018
  • Mr Bunter was fantastic.

    Ms Maxwell, Allen Hoole Solicitors – February 2018
  • Pretty impressive work done by Ann Kiernan.

    Mr Dugan, Adams Whyte Solicitors - October 2016.
  • Alan Henderson is a leading expert in his field and I have used him for a number of serious cases over the years.

    Stuart Duke, Tuckers Solicitors - November 2017
  • Competitive price – within LAA Standards; approachable, polite staff and great expert.

    Ms McKernan, Lawtons Solicitors – January 2018
  • Mr Armstrong delivered clear and cogent evident and was an impressive witness.

    Mr Emery, Emery Halil & Brown Solicitors - May 2017.
  • Quality, well informed report.

    Mr Walker, Eaton Smith LLP - May 2016.
  • Very useful expert in the context of the case; professional/pleasant to deal with.

    Mr Hollingsworth, 2 Kings Bench Walk - July 2016.
  • Fab service from your Ross Donnelly & Mark Henderson - thank you.

    Ms Edington, Thomas More Chambers – March 2018
  • Julian Dunnill was incredibly helpful and knowledgeable. I will definitely recommend him as an expert.

    Ms Duong, 23 Essex Street – October 2017
  • We are very grateful to Mr Prime.  He made himself available at short notice and was contactable over the phone beforehand in order to clarify/confirm certain aspects of the case.

    Mr Gunn, Mark Jones & Partners Solicitors – May 2018
  • Mr Brown’s report was excellent and I have no doubt this contributed in no small part to the result.

    Ms Tracy Reynolds, James Murray Solicitors - September 2016.
  • May we thank Mrs Allan for an excellent report.

    Ms Payne-James, FHC Experts for Law & Mediation – March 2018
  • Mr Donnelly was extremely helpful and the report was prepared very promptly.

    Ms Clasper, Beecham Peacock Solicitors - January 2017.
  • The service we have received is 5* and very much appreciated.

    Ms Bradley, E C Lidster & Co Solicitors - November 2017
  • Quick, accurate and easy to speak to expert instructed (Mr Tarpey).

    Ms Ripley, JSP Law Solicitors & Advocates - December 2017
  • Expert always contactable and very helpful (Alan Henderson).

    Ms McKernan, Lawtons Solicitors – January 2018
  • Speed, approachability, professional but friendly north east ethos.

    Mr Harris, Foys Solicitors - December 2016.
  • Instant reply on whether they can help or not; excellent with keeping us updated; fantastic report.

    Ms Dimitrova, Lansbury Worthington Solicitors - April 2018
  • Mr Brown was excellent in Court.  His evidence was extremely helpful – the District Judge even commented so in his pronouncement.

    Ms Perrin, Roy Foreman & Co Solicitors - June 2016.
  • Communication with your office was always efficient and prompt.

    Ms Lord, Pritchard Joyce & Hinds - November 2016.
  • We always find the company to be financially accessible, very professional and helpful; you always have an expert in the field required.

    Ms Child, Cohen Cramer Solicitors - November 2016.
  • Very prompt attention to email correspondence.

    Ms Hughes, Hughes Murphy Solicitors - August 2016.
  • Adrian Armstrong was excellent both in terms of the quality of his report and his general approach.

    Ms Thompson, Waterfords Solicitors - March 2017.
  • Mr Armstrong was a pleasure to work with, extremely professional and generous with his time and expertise.

    Ms Hughes, Hughes Murphy Solicitors - April 2017.
  • KBC routinely provide top quality assistance in drug drive matters.

    Mr Dormer, Nelson Guest & Partners Solicitors - July 2016.
  • Pleasant and efficient replies and support by all staff.

    Mr Jepson, GWB Harthills Solicitors – November 2017
  • Always reliable; thorough reports.

    Ms Hall, Alderson Law LLP – September 2017.
  • Ann Kiernan was excellent.

    Mr Williams, Exchange Chambers - March 2017.
  • Excellent reputation.

    Mr Reid, Gerard Maguire Solicitors – May 2018
  • Mr Keenan is clearly an expert in his field of the highest order and I would not hesitate to recommend him to others or use him in any other case.

    Mr John Weate, RMNJ Solicitors - June 2016.
  • Mrs Tweedy was extremely professional, expert and helpful.

    Mr Giollaiosa O’Lideadha SC, The Law Library of Ireland - April 2017.
  • I was impressed by the time and detail taken in producing the proposal of (cell site analysis) work which made it really easy to understand how the service was going to help us.

    Ms Pattni, London Borough of Brent Council - December 2017
  • Very good, in fact excellent!

    Ms Thompson, Brockbanks Solicitors – February 2018
  • Please thank Richard Brown very much for the rapid turn round of this report.

    Mr Rowland, Gotelee Solicitors – March 2018
  • Will definitely use KBC again.

    Ms Bhamra, B M V Solicitors - May 2017.
  • John Tarpey's evidence was critical to the success of this case.

    Mr Thomas QC, Lincoln House Chambers – February 2018
  • Impressed with all aspects – knowledge, presentation, lines of communication.

    Mr Tongue, The Johnson Partnership Solicitors – January 2018
  • Many years ago, when working for another firm, we regularly consulted yourselves and always received an outstanding service.  It’s good to find that after probably 25+ years, your standards have not slipped.

    Mr Wilson, a2z Licensing – March 2018
  • Cheapest and clearest quote.

    Mr Mock, Everett Tomlin Lloyd & Pratt Solicitors - June 2016.
  • Mr Tarpey was very knowledgeable about this subject and explained well.

    DI Everest, Police Scotland – August 2017.
  • Extremely knowledgeable; helped in achieving a super result for our client.

    Mr Dormer, Nelson Guest & Partners Solicitors - September 2016.
  • Good and early access to the expert; very fast turn around on report.

    Mr Hatton, Broudie Jackson & Canter Solicitors - July 2016.
  • Mr Prime was excellent in all respects. A very professional witness. I will be recommending him to chambers.

    Ged Doran, Barrister, Lincoln House Chambers - June 2016.
  • Prompt and clear expert advice.

    Mr Hashmi, A B V Solicitors - December 2016.
  • Consistent quality service in speedy timeframe.

    Ms Jones, McKenzies Solicitors - November 2016.
  • Alan Henderson was an excellent witness; very professional, very well versed in his own field and excellent in presenting matters to the jury.  I would not hesitate to use him again in similar cases or recommend his services to others.

    Mr Peter Corrigan, Carmelite Chambers - June 2016.
  • Easy and quick to contact the company and speak to the expert or a member of their team.

    Ms Roberts, Lewis Nedas Law Limited - October 2016.
  • Local, efficient, competitive and quick.

    Mr Hodgson, Hodgson Coulthard & Co Solicitors – February 2018
  • Thank you so much for your impeccable service.

    Ms McCarthy, Brian Jackson & Co Solicitors – November 2017
  • Report was delivered on time as promised.

    Mr Jones, Steel & Shamash Solicitors - December 2017
  • Lee Fagan was a pleasure to work with: very straightforward and thorough.

    Mr Hanna, John J Rice & Co Solicitors – October 2017
  • We compared you with another less costly service, but considered you to be more professional.

    Mr Brady, Davey Law – February 2018
  • Quick and clear report.

    Mr Surzyn, P C B Solicitors - March 2017.
  • Excellent expertise, helpful service and quick turnaround.

    Mr Maher, Patterson Law Solicitors – October 2017
  • Very impressed with Dr Davey’s professionalism.

    Mr Britton, Mohammed Rustam Khan Solicitors - June 2016.
  • You provide a good service and work within the constraints of the LAA funding.

    Mr Arthur, O'Garra's Solicitors – April 2018
  • It is about professionalism, efficiency, attention to detail, courtesy and kindness.  It is a very, very long time since I have dealt with any group that was as quick to respond and as efficient as you all were.

    Ms S, Private Client – April 2018
  • Very good testimony on all accounts; measured and reasonable.  There is nothing I would change about Mr Dunnill’s evidence or manner in giving it.

    Mr Penman, KBW Chambers - January 2018
  • Quick, efficient, approachable expert (Mr Fagan), with excellent communication skills.

    Ms Duke, Davison Flynn Duke Solicitors – January 2018
  • Very efficient and in close contact.

    Ms Roberts, Bernard Chill & Axtell Solicitors - May 2016.
  • We have been extremely impressed with your work throughout the entire course of the proceedings.

    Mr Maher, Patterson Law - November 2017
  • Consistently good reports.

    Ms Williams, Red Kite Law LLP Solicitors - August 2016.
  • Outstanding.  Mr Prime was conscious of duty but compelling in his approach to the evidence.

    Mr Temkin, Exchange Chambers – April 2018
  • I would not hesitate both to use and recommend Mr Armstrong again.

    Mr Baker, Howell & Co Solicitors - June 2016.
  • I am grateful for Richard Brown’s assistance in this matter.  It is surprisingly difficult to find experts who are not only experts in their field, but who report their findings and conclusions in such a coherent manner.

    Dr Shane Hausfield, EBR Attridge LLP - June 2016.
  • Highly professional service; exceeded a very tight deadline.

    Mr Mather, Patterson Law Solicitors - June 2017.
  • Prompt, succinct, communicative and pleasant to deal with.

    Mr Berg, Cox Burley Solicitors – January 2018
  • KBC’s efficiency never ceases to amaze me!

    Mr Barnes, Allington Hughes Solicitors – January 2018
  • Cost effective, reliable and professional.

    Ms Hudson, Bullivant Law Solicitors & Advocates – October 2017
  • Able to act fast and produce good reports for the court.

    Ms Knaggs, Brown Beer Nixon Mallon Solicitors - May 2017.
  • Fast response, friendly, clear explanations of requirements and findings at all stages.

    Ms Hullock, Hullock & Co Solicitors - February 2017.
  • Very quick, very clear report.  Excellent service at all times.

    Ms Roberts, The Purkiss Partnership Solicitors – March 2018
  • I don't know what you are paying Alan Henderson, but I'd say it isn't enough.

    Stuart Duke, Tuckers Solicitors - November 2017
  • The service Ryan Knight provided was excellent.

    Mr Chadwick, Robert Lizar Solicitors – January 2018
  • Renowned expertise.

    Mr Reid, Gerard Maguire Solicitors - June 2016.
  • We have worked with you for a number of years and find your work accurate and reliable.

    Ms Amin, Brooklyn Solicitors – April 2018
  • Alan Henderson is always contactable, his work is always impeccable and juries have always liked him.

    Stuart Duke, Tuckers Solicitors - November 2017
  • Everyone who works at KBC is extremely friendly and helpful. The reports are always quality.

    Mr Warburton, Jones Knowles Warburton Solicitors - February 2017.
  • Gave a very knowledgeable and detailed account which no doubt assisted in securing the successful appeal.

    Mr Wills, Drystone Chambers, November 2017
  • I found Paul Wilson to be excellent in every way.  I would have no hesitation in recommending him as a first class expert in the proper analysis of DNA profiles.

    Ms McDermott, Barrister, The Bar of Northern Ireland - October 2016.
  • Julian Dunnill’s professionalism is very, very good. His knowledge is without parallel.

    Mr Nowell, Finn Gledhill Solicitors – September 2017.
  • Julian Dunnill’s professionalism is very, very good. His knowledge is without parallel.

    Mr Nowell, Finn Gledhill Solicitors – September 2017.
  • Keep doing what you do.

    Mr Ripley, Cohen Cramer Solicitors – November 2017
  • Ultimately, the mere fact that we had instructed yourselves as experts and the difficulties the police had … in my view went some way towards convincing the CPS that they needed to review the case and ultimately discontinue it.

    Mr Bowker, Edwards Duthie Solicitors – April 2018
  • Thank you very, very much - impeccable service as per usual.

    Ms McCarthy, Brian Jackson & So Solicitors – April 2018
  • John Tarpey is straightforward, robust, likeable (generally and in the presentation of his evidence) and very knowledgeable about his subject.

    DCI Hawkes, Bedfordshire Police – August 2017.
  • Mr Prime was able to provide assistance with matters as they arose, which was invaluable.

    Ms Clasper, Beecham Peacock Solicitors – November 2017
  • Ease of communication, rapid response to queries.

    Ms Moore, Jim Rafferty Solicitor - March 2017.
  • Extremely prompt responses and case very well managed.

    Mr Atkinson, Freeman & Co Solicitors - April 2017.
  • Everyone concerned went out of their way to provide an extremely prompt and efficient service.

    Ms Elgy, Hewitts Solicitors - January 2017.
  • Reading through your website gave us confidence.

    Mrs Henry, Private Client - May 2017.
  • The expert witness was easily contactable and diligent in his work.

    Mr Mather, Patterson Law Solicitors - June 2017.
  • You are considered the ‘go to’ expert service within our firm.

    Mr Tismond, Taylor Goodchild Solicitors – January 2018
  • Alan Henderson was excellent from beginning to end.

    Mr Cameron, McLennan Adam Davis Solicitors - June 2017.
  • Always our first choice due to the assistance given.

    Mr Hodnett, Sheppards Solicitors Ltd - May 2017.
  • Responsive, fast turnaround, quality reports, legal aid rates.

    Ms Kelsall, Forbes Solicitors - April 2018
  • Very prompt service and very professional.

    Ms Gill Francis, Stephensons Solicitors LLP - September 2016.
  • Mr Dunnill was excellent and I would definitely use him again.

    Ms Francis, St James Solicitors - September 2016.
  • Speedy, efficient and professional as always!

    Ms Sidgwick, H P Gower Solicitors – March 2018
  • The right expert for the job.

    Ms Dinoff, B L M Solicitors - February 2017.
  • Used you many times previously and the service is always exceptional.

    Mr Barnes, Allington Hughes Solicitors – January 2018
  • Always helpful. Detailed reports.

    Ms Hall, Alderson Law LLP - March 2017.
  • Would use the service again with no hesitation.

    Mr Glover, Pringle Law Limited – January 2018
  • Very good.

    Mr Connell, 5 St Andrew's Hill Chambers – May 2018
  • Guy Cooper’s written report, oral evidence and the manner in which he presented it were instrumental in achieving a successful outcome to the matter.

    Mr Scott, 3 Temple Gardens Chambers - January 2017.
  • Superb outcome in the case ... as a direct result of Mr Prime discussing matters with his counterpart.  Very, very impressive.  Good, too, with the client.

    Mr Temkin, Exchange Chambers – April 2018
  • A comprehensive report produced within a reasonable timescale, well within times approved by the court.

    Mr Walker, Walker & Co Solicitors - July 2016.
  • Mr Tarpey was very helpful and approachable; he made a complex matter very simple for the jury.

    Ms Hudson, Bullivant Law Solicitors & Advocates – November 2017
  • Responded efficiently with clear advice.

    Ms Lyon, Pickup & Scott Solicitors - December 2017
  • Richard Brown’s knowledge of the subject matter was excellent, his report clear and detailed, and his explanations … instilled confidence.  I would happily use him again.

    Mr Ryan, Apex Chambers – February 2018
  • I found your expert extremely pleasant and she gave her evidence confidently and knowledgably.

    Mr Priestley, Opus Law - January 2017.
  • Efficient and organised; reasonable quote.

    Mr Nash, Noble Solicitors - July 2016.
  • High quality reports.

    Ms Schaefer, L P Evans Solicitors - January 2017.
  • The attention to detail in Mr Tarpey’s preparation and his knowledge of the case shone through when he was cross-examined.

    Mr Thomas QC, Lincoln House Chambers – February 2018

Keith Borer Consultants is a division of Orchid Cellmark Ltd, a company registered in England at 16 Blacklands Way, Abingdon, OX14 1DY.

Registered No. 4045527; VAT registration No. GB 750 0292 64

Website developed by Problue Solutions